2014 Synagogue Church building collapse

Coordinates: 6°32′48″N 3°16′22″E / 6.5467°N 3.2728°E / 6.5467; 3.2728

The 2014 Synagogue Church Building Collapse took place on Friday, 12 September, when a guesthouse located within the Synagogue church premises around Ikotun-Egbe area of Lagos State collapsed completely to the ground.^[2] The National Emergency Management Agency (NAMA) and other emergency services were criticized for withholding information about the accident and much remained unclear about the number of deaths and their nationalities .

Collapse of guesthouse

On 12 September 2014, a guesthouse collapsed in the SCOAN's premises in Lagos killing at least 115 people, 84 of them South Africans.^[3]

Casualties

Nigerian emergency services refused to release the nationalities of the victims, but other countries have provided some details about those who died. The vast majority of casualties were from South Africa, but the nationalities of dozens of people remained unclear.^[1]

Casualties by nationality

Nation	Number
South Africa	84
Zimbabwe	1
Nationality unknown	30
Total	115

Reactions

Governor Babatunde Fashola of Lagos State has ordered all church workers away from the scene in-order to properly rescue trapped bodies.^[4] The government also claim the church did not get government approval before construction.^[5] Journalist Nicholas Ibekwe released an audio recording that allegedly captures TB Joshua offering bribes to journalists in return for reporting the incident in a way that portrayed the church favorably.^[6]

Cause

The senior pastor of the church, T. B. Joshua has linked the tragedy to a strange aircraft "hovering" above the building shortly before it fell.^[7] A video was released on YouTube that allegedly showed the plane hovering around the building before its collapse.^[8] However, the coroner's report unequivocally found the cause to be due to structural failure.^[9] Three government agencies, (the Nigeria Building And Road Research Instititute (NBBRI), the Council for the Regulation of Engineering in Nigeria (COREN) and the Building Collapse Prevention Guild (BCPG)) examined the site and found the following inadequacies:

• Inadequate beams of 750mm by 225mm (should have been 900mm by 300mm)
• Inadequately reinforced columns (should have been reinforced with 12 x Y25 bars or 20 x Y20mm bars. Instead they used 10 x Y20 bars (as seen in the video released by SCOAN).
• Inadequate bearing pressure for the central column due to the 2m x 2m x 0.9m foundations.
• Failure to introduce rigid zones for bracing the structure and did not design the frames as an unbraced structure.
• Failure to provide movement joints that could have absorbed any movement due to creep, contraction, expansion and differential settlement etc..
• 8 out of the 12 main beams of the structure failed because they were undersized, under-reinforced (both in tension and shear), the tension bars were poorly anchored to the column supports and 8 x Y20 was used instead of 14 x Y20.
• The ground floor columns were slender and readily gave in to buckling ^[10]

Trial

Joshua failed to appear at a November 2015 hearing ^[11] SCOAN's lawyers have filed multiple applications to stay the proceedings ^[12][13][14] The Lagos state government has repeatedly insisted that this case receive trial.^[15]
Local radio host Freeze, drew unfavorable comparisons to a similar incident in Lekki, in which Lekki Gardens managing director Richard Nyong was jailed for illegally unsealing a building that he was having constructed and that which later collapsed.^[16][17] He was upset because Nyong had been arrested quickly, Joshua had not.^[18]

References